FIFA Should Fix More Than Blatter

by Minky Worden Director of Global Initiatives at Human Rights Watch 03.06.2015

Sepp Blatter stepping down as president of football’s governing body, FIFA, is no fix for the epic problems facing the World Cup’s organizers - and other mega-sporting events.

FIFA’s (non-corruption) problems are legion. Migrant workers shouldn’t toil in deadly heat to construct monumental stadiums: no sports fan wants to watch from seats that workers died to build. Sponsors shouldn’t want to promote games in repressive countries that threaten and jail critics. Journalists shouldn’t be beaten and jailed for reporting on abuses tied to the World Cup. Women shouldn’t be banned from watching football matches. 

Whoever takes over in FIFA’s top job should act fast to end the abuses against migrant laborers building infrastructure for the 2022 World Cup in Qatar, where workers are bound by an oppressive sponsorship system known as kafala. The new leadership should also insist that ahead of the 2018 World Cup, Russia prevents the rampant exploitation of migrant workers that the government tolerated for years before last year’s Sochi Olympics.

The recent trend of repressive leaders wanting to host mega-sporting events is one to stop. China, Qatar, Russia, Azerbaijan, and Kazakhstan want to host global contests because it brings the chance to burnish reputations and divert media attention from domestic problems.

FIFA and the International Olympic Committee monitor preparations for their events in minute detail, but don’t take pains to assess who gets to host. Both should adopt human rights impact assessments.

FIFA’s new leaders have time to do the right thing. They should insist that Qatar investigates and ends construction worker deaths and reforms its kafala system. They should demand rigorous labor inspections to ensure that Russia protects workers building World Cup sites, and insist that everyone employed in factories supplying materials for Cup venues – including prisoners – are not victims of forced labor, are paid properly, and are protected from workplace abuses.

In sports, we demand everyone plays fair. But the ugly truth is that human rights-abusing hosts are breaking the rules and getting away with it, on labor rights and on press freedom, while FIFA watches from the sidelines. Let’s hope Blatter’s departure provokes that change.

As Human Rights Watch's Director of Global Initiatives, Minky Worden develops and implements international outreach and advocacy campaigns. She previously served as Human Rights Watch's Media Director, working with the world’s journalists to help them cover crises, wars, human rights abuses and political developments in some 90 countries worldwide. Before joining Human Rights Watch in 1998, Ms. Worden lived and worked in Hong Kong as an adviser to Democratic Party chairman Martin Lee and worked at the Department of Justice in Washington, D.C. as a speechwriter for the U.S. Attorney General and in the Executive Office for US Attorneys. A member of the Council on Foreign Relations, Ms. Worden speaks Cantonese and German, and is an elected member of the Overseas Press Club's Board of Governors. She is the editor of The Unfinished Revolution (Seven Stories Press, 2012) and China's Great Leap (Seven Stories Press, 2008), and the co-editor of Torture

© 2015 Human Rights Watch. All rights reserved.

For Human Rights Watch site, please click here.

To follow what's new on Facts & Arts, please click here.

Related articles on Facts & Arts:

The clever politics of Sepp Blatter's 'resignation' from FIFA

by Mark DoidgeAdded 03.06.2015
And so Sepp Blatter has defied all expectations and announced his intention to step aside from the presidency of FIFA after 17 years at the helm. Despite numerous scandals afflicting the organisation he ran, he won four successive elections....

How UEFA could leave FIFA and launch its own World Cup

by Mark Doidge and Thomas F CarterAdded 02.06.2015
“….UEFA could secede from FIFA and declare itself the sole authority over European football…..” “….the European nations are the economic engine of the World Cup,….. “…..UEFA could establish the Champions League as the legitimate rival spectacle...

The Soccer Mafia

by Ian BurumaAdded 28.05.2015
“The contemporary alliance of Western interests – in the arts and higher education no less than in sports – with rich, undemocratic powers involves compromises that might easily damage established reputations. One way to deflect the attention is...

Rate this article

Click the stars to rate

Recent articles